by Shane Conto, Staff Writer
When is something the right thing to do when it is a “bad” thing to do? Many films struggle to capture such moral gray areas, as it is much easier to convey conflict between “good” and “evil.” You would probably expect a film that tackles gray areas to be a dark and brooding drama or thriller. But that is not necessarily the truth, as evidenced by the fun and engaging new true story drama, The Duke. Kempton Bunton (Jim Broadbent) was a man who wanted to take it to the British government when he saw something that was not right. How does he do that? He steals a prized possession of the kingdom, a portrait of the Duke of Wellington.
If you know who did it already, where does the conflict come from? Director Roger Michell takes a different approach to Bunton’s story. This is not a “crime” film, even if a supposed crime took place. This film is about something else entirely. It is about a man who is trying to stand up for what is right. It is about the commitment of a father to his family. It is about what makes an act of crime right or wrong to begin with. Writers Richard Bean and Clive Coleman accomplish a lot with this story, and will even surprise you along the way. One of the The Duke’s biggest accomplishments is that it tricks the audience into believing what would be the simplest outcome when it is so much more than that.
Michell has a lot on his plate with structuring this story — how does he do? There is a tonal tightrope that Michell walks, but he can make a film so decidedly British. The film can be funny and snarky, but still pull on your emotions and have an impact. There are plenty of laughs to be had with this sharp script from Bean and Coleman, along with some charismatic performances. There is plenty of room for emotions as well, as the script offers up some strongly written scenes that see Kempton connect with those he loves. Given that this film is about the aftermath of a heist, there are some fun moments that pack in some suspense and tension. The Duke might not be the most bold film from a technical standpoint, but it sure offers up plenty of story and emotions.
When the trailer was released, it certainly appeared that Broadbent would steal the show, but did he? Oh… he sure does. This film is a perfect showcase for Broadbent’s wonderful charisma as an actor. He brings so much charm to the role that you cannot help but love him from the start. Helen Mirren offers up an equally sassy and charming turn as his wife, Dorothy. Matthew Goode and James Wilby offer up some strong support in the trial-based scenes, which are certainly some of the most fun in the film, and that might be surprising. But a special shoutout needs to be offered to Fionn Whitehead whose turn as Jackie Bunton (Kempton’s son) is so important to the success of the film narratively and emotionally.
Does The Duke offer up more than what might appear to be a safe British drama? Michell’s film is a wonderful delight full of humor and emotion. There is a strong anchoring message about duty, right versus wrong, and commitment to one’s community and family. With the big movie season on the horizon, this is a wonderful little flick worth your time.
Score: 8/10
You can follow Shane Conto on Twitter, Instagram, and Letterboxd