by Shane Conto, Staff Writer
We all know that Jim from The Office turned out to be a good director. But did you know that the OTHER Jim from The Office has a new directorial feature coming your way to the big screen? For those who get this “Asian Jim” reference, good for you. But in all seriousness (at least for the time being), Randall Park is coming your way with his new comedy, Shortcomings. This is an interesting offering, as it focuses on a trio of young Asian Americans who are each coming to today’s society with completely different perspectives. Based on the graphic novel by Adrian Tomine (who also wrote the script), this film has plenty to say about the Asian American experience.
What are the major themes and experiences that Park tackles with this film? There are a few, and they are embedded in the specific experiences of each of our characters. Let’s start with Ben (Justin H. Min). To say that Ben has a lot of problems with how Asian Americans are treated in America is an understatement. He has biting and angry takes on every single possible topic that might come up, one of which is relationship dynamics. There is tension in Ben’s relationships with the Asian women in his life because he has a thing for white women. That tension feels well earned, and is explored within the characters. This is also important for Ally Maki’s Miko, as she is mixed race. But her involvement with a character who is white passing and leans heavily into Asian culture adds more depth to the conversation. Then you have Sherry Cola’s Alice, a lesbian who is not out to her family (who would be the most open to her truth). Tomine provides even more to chew on, and that is the most impressive part of the film.
What about the overall story? Things are not going well for Ben and Miko. There is always tension and discomfort in their relationship. Miko makes a big choice by going out to New York City for an internship, and leaving Ben with a “break.” Ben takes this as an opportunity to explore relationships with some white women in his life. But when Alice also makes the leap to the east coast, Ben must confront his structured and rigid life. Shortcomings has some twists and turns, which deliver plenty of opportunities for Park and his cast to explore the complexities of human dynamics. On top of being funny, that is what this film does best. There are plenty of moments and beats that feel real and relatable, making this an accessible journey.
But what is the biggest issue with the film? Ben is downright unlikable. Sure, Ben is not supposed to be an easy character to get along with. His journey is the core of the film. But it comes off as too much, and the resolution comes too late. There are so many great things going on for this film — as the performances are top-notch across the board and the themes are engaging — but Ben gets so bad that you almost don’t want to watch him anymore towards the end, which is a big problem.
But do Shortcomings and Park still deliver? Luckily, there is plenty to make the film enjoyable and meaningful despite Ben and his horribly unwatchable disposition. Regardless of the rough road to get there, Ben’s arc is intriguing, and delivers a satisfying and thoughtful conclusion. Park offers up a layered and fun experience.
Rating: Liked It
Shortcomings is currently playing in theaters
You can read more from Shane Conto, and follow him on Twitter, Instagram, and Letterboxd