by Shane Conto
What if a super intelligent computer decided that it would take the fate of humanity into its own “hands”? That certainly sounds my worst nightmare, but it also seems like a script idea that has plenty of potential! HBO Max thought that this story had the potential too with their latest film streaming now called Superintelligence. What if the story added the layer of this computer following the behavior of the most average human of all? Sounds interesting enough. What if that average human just happens to be Melissa McCarthy? Interesting choice!
But most importantly…does the film deliver?
Superintelligence is the latest film from director Ben Falcone who has made a career of directing comedies that might not always deliver. He has also made a habit of casting his wife, McCarthy, in his films…which makes a lot of sense for her casting. In all honesty, the film doesn’t really feel like it has a distinct feel and personality to it. The visuals are very glossy and bright while also lacking any grit or energy to it. The pacing, for the most part, zips along at a good pace. The biggest issues with the film are the balancing of the story and tone.
The film starts off very funny and lighthearted before taking a darker and emotional turn towards the third act.
Unfortunately, that tonal shift does not land. From a story perspective, it works so well throughout the first act. The sharp dialogue and chemistry between McCarthy and the computer under the guise of James Corden is perfect. There are plenty of laughs which honestly surprise me so much. But then the real plot kicks into gear and it turns out to just be a cliche rom-com. That is where the film fails. McCarthy and her ex, played by Bobby Cannavale, might have some fun banter and chemistry, but the whole middle of the film feels derivative and worn. The sassy computer disappears for long stretches and a growing military/government subplot begins to feel distracting. Then you get a world ending and emotional third act that feels rushed and out of place. What a rollercoaster ride of the film this one is? This erratic swinging of stories is not dissimilar to the issues with HBO Max’s other comedy, An American Pickle.
One of the bright spots of the film is the charismatic and game cast.
Melissa McCarthy is an actress with tons of talent, but she is so easily misused. However, McCarthy has plenty of charisma and delivers plenty of laughs. Even if the later parts of the film feels out of place, McCarthy feels right at home delivering some emotional moments. Her character may be the most average of all humans but she is also incredibly relatable. Then there is James Corden. Mostly just appearing in vocal form, Corden provides plenty of laughs with his impressive banter with McCarthy. This is certainly some of the funniest material in the film and it is a real shame when Corden is sidelined for stretches of the film. You can tell Bobby Cannavale was having fun with his role as McCarthy’s ex. Brian Tyree Henry is a nice addition to the supporting cast who carries many of the side plots scenes throughout the film.
In conclusion, does Superintelligence hold itself together enough to deliver a satisfying comedic experience?
Not quite. The first act of the film really delivers and makes you wish that the film focused on those situations and the quality banter. The second act might grab the attention of those who love their rom-coms…but might alienate those who do not. The third just tries really hard to bring a gravity to the film while forcing both of the first two acts together. The film hooks you at the start and attracts you with a talented cast but in the end loses you.
Grade: C